How to Sell a Historic Home in Athens, Georgia

Selling a Historic Home in Athens: What You Need to Know

Athens' historic neighborhoods — Cobbham, Boulevard, Normaltown, and parts of Five Points — contain some of the most beautiful and unique homes in Georgia. But selling a historic home is fundamentally different from selling a standard suburban property.

After handling dozens of historic home sales over my career, here's what I've learned about maximizing value while navigating the unique challenges.

Why Historic Homes Are Different

Historic homes attract a specific buyer: someone who values character, craftsmanship, and location over move-in-ready convenience. Your marketing, pricing, and preparation strategy needs to reflect this.

What historic home buyers care about:

• Original architectural details (hardwood floors, mantels, molding, windows)
• Neighborhood character and walkability
• Lot size and mature landscaping
• Proximity to downtown Athens and UGA
• The story of the home

What they worry about:

• Deferred maintenance costs
• Outdated electrical, plumbing, and HVAC
• Foundation and structural issues
• Historic district restrictions on modifications
• Insurance costs

Pricing Strategy for Historic Homes

Standard comparable sales analysis often doesn't work for historic homes. Two homes on the same street can vary by $200K based on condition, original features, and renovations.

My approach:

1. Comparable sales within historic districts (not generic Athens comps)

2. Replacement cost analysis for original features (hand-carved mantels, original heart pine floors)

3. Lot value assessment using my landscape architecture background

4. Buyer pool analysis — understanding who's actively searching for historic properties

Preparation: What to Fix and What to Leave

Fix:

• Safety issues (electrical, structural, roof)
• Cosmetic updates that don't alter character (fresh paint, landscaping)
• Kitchen and bathroom functionality (buyers expect modern plumbing)

Leave alone:

• Original hardwood floors (even if imperfect — buyers want authenticity)
• Original windows (repair, don't replace — this is a major value factor)
• Architectural details (crown molding, built-ins, mantels)
• Period-appropriate fixtures

Marketing a Historic Home

Standard MLS photos and descriptions don't do historic homes justice. My approach includes:

1. Architectural photography that highlights original details

2. Lifestyle videography showing the neighborhood context

3. Written narrative telling the home's story and provenance

4. Targeted marketing to historic home enthusiast networks, preservation groups, and UGA-affiliated buyers

Historic District Considerations

If your home is in a locally designated historic district, buyers need to know about:

• Certificate of Appropriateness requirements for exterior changes
• Tax incentives for rehabilitation (Georgia Historic Preservation Tax Credit)
• Restrictions on materials, colors, and additions

I present these as advantages, not limitations. Historic district protections preserve neighborhood character and property values.

The Bottom Line

Your historic home is irreplaceable. Marketing it requires someone who understands both its architectural value and the Athens buyer market. A generic selling approach will leave money on the table.

Thinking about selling your historic property? Schedule a consultation and I'll give you a personalized assessment of your home's market value.

---

*Dean Bright holds a degree in Landscape Architecture from UGA, giving him unique expertise in evaluating historic properties, site design, and land value in Athens.*